May 252007
 

I’ve just come across a page on the BBC Children’s website ‘explaining’ volcanoes [What causes volcanoes?] and it is full of basic errors of geology. If the BBC can’t get simple facts right for children what hope do we have in creating a proper understanding of our planet and our subject. I appreciate that they have to keep things simple for children but that is no excuse for fundamental errors of fact!

To Fisk the article …
Inside the earth’s core there is a red-hot liquid rock, called magma.

The Earth’s core has absolutely nothing to do with volcanoes. It is the Earth’s crust that has magma inside it – the core is 2900km away!

Note also that it is “Earth’s” – it is a formal name of a planet, earth is soil.

Volcanoes happen when magma rises to the surface of the earth, which causes bubbles of gas to appear in it. This gas can cause pressure to build up in the mountain, and it eventually explodes. When the magma bursts out of the earth, it is called lava.

This is not true of all volcanoes (and certainly not true of Hawaii which was the subject of the story to which this page linked). Also the gas bubbles won’t usually appear in the magma until the pressure is released and the eruption starts.

In a survey of school geology textbooks the factual error rate was found to be at least one per page! The producers of so called scientific content really do need to check their facts properly and the BBC should do much better.

  2 Responses to “Geology Errors on Children's BBC Website”

  1. The BBC is renowned for inaccuracies.

  2. Oh! how right you are! But not only the BBC is full of geology errors, I can quote you others which for me are mistakes, in many volcano sites.
    Regards,
    Werner Luis

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.